Skyla was well into her third trimester on the day that Jonathan finally heard from Tony. He received a text with only an address in it. She was due at any moment, and he didnโt want to leave her. But, he had to go meet Tony and get some answers. She assured him that she would be fine and that the baby probably wouldnโt come until the next morning. He hoped she was right. He kissed her, she wished him luck, and then he was gone.
The address from Tonyโs text was in Newcrest, so Jonathan assumed that they were meeting at some new club or something. He didnโt recall there being any homes in Newcrest, but boy oh boy was he wrong. The address was for a house, and itย was on the largest lot right across the street from the country club where he had his bachelor party. It was enormousโmaybeย even bigger than the Pruett estate. At first, Jonathan walked past the house. There was no way that was the place Tony wanted to meet. He looked at the text and looked back at the address on the mailbox and was thoroughly confused.ย This canโt be it. Howย can he afford all this? Whoโs house is this?ย As he stood there on the sidewalk, dumbfounded by what he saw, everything slowly began to make sense.
He grew more and more despondent as the scene became more real to him. IโฆI canโt believe it. This canโt be happening. How could he do this to me?ย He wasnโt going toย get any answers by standingย on the front lawn, so he pressed on toward the door and knocked.
Tony was expecting him and left the door unlocked. Jonathan let himself in. Figuring out that he had been taken by his best friend was already painful enough. Discovering that it was pre-meditated and was intended to hurt himย was like a fatal wound. What he saw in the foyerย was the blow that finished him off.
It was almost as if there was a tiny section of his heart that wanted to hold out in hopes that all of this was just some big misunderstanding. But seeing it stand thereโฆstrong and regal… He had never actually cast eyes on it before, but he knew what it was, where it came from, and what it represented. Seeing it stand there in all of its glory crushed all feelings of hope he had and confirmed suspicions. He couldnโt move. He wanted to break down and cry right there, but he needed to know why.
Tony came out to greet him.ย โJonathan! Come in. Can Vincent make you a drink?โ
How can he be so casual? He invites me to his house like a guest? Jonathanโs feelings of anger were replaced with embarrassment and sadness. Tony wasย a trusted friend, and he had betrayed him. It took Jonathan a minute to find his words. When he did, they were broken and drenched in despair. โIsnโt it enough that you swindledย me? You had to steal my family heirloom too?โ
โAhhh, I knew youโd catch on quickly. But, youโre notย thatย smart, are ya now?โ Tony patted him on the arm and motioned for Jonathan to sit with him.
Jonathan couldnโt take his eyes off Tony. He was sitting right next to him, but he didnโt recognize him. โHow could you do this to me?โ
โEasy! You let me.โ Tony shrugged his shoulders casually.
Jonathan was still embarrassed and saddened, but now the anger was rising again. โHow would Iย let you do this? I would never let anyone steal from me!โ
Tony raised his left eyebrow in surprise. He hadnโt realized just how clueless and irresponsible Jonathan was until just then. He pulled out a piece of paper from his breast pocket and gave it to Jonathan. โDidnโt you sign this?โ It wasย his copy of the Power of Attorney document. โWhen you signed this, you gave me permission to do as I saw fit. You gave me theย same power you have. Soโฆstealing is such a harsh word. Letโs say I put your funds to better use, he he he.โ
โWhy you son of aโ
โJonathan? Oh, hello,โ Miss Corleonesi said. โI didnโt know youโd be here. Can I get you something to drink?โ
โHeโs fine, mom. Thank you. Please leave us.โ
Jonathanโs emotions ranย rampant for the rest of the night. Tony would say something that made him angry, but then he would say something else to put him on the verge of tears. This dance took place all night, and Tony was having the time of his life.
Jonathanโs voice cracked as he tried to hold it together. โWe wereย friends, Tony! I trusted you! How could you do this?! WHY?โ
โWell, letโs just say thatย your family heirloom is my familyโs heirloom too.โ
โWHAT?! Youโre not a Pruett! Youโre crazy!โ
โOh, but Iย am a Pruett. Seeโฆremember when I told you my father kept reaching out to me? I finally met him just to get him off my back. He told me about his familyโฆmy family. He told me who I really was and how important I should be. You know Iโm a family man. I had to join him and take back my rightful place.โ
โWhat place?! This doesnโt explain you being a Pruett!โ
โSeeโฆ Thatโs the thing with you Pruetts. Youโre so arrogant and smug. You think youโre the only ones out there who can live like you live and have what you have. You think youโre so high and mighty and nothing could ever touch you. Well, I did it, and it was easy! You Pruetts are gullible and stupid, and you donโt deserve anything you have! You donโt even recognize all of your family members when you have the heir talks with your sons!โ
โWHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT?โ
โIs everything ok over here,โ Vincent asked with a menacing look.
โWhat is this,โ Jonathan asked. โIs he your body guard now?โ
โOne story at a time, kid. Weโre fine Vincent. I think Mr. Legacy can use a drink thoughโฆ Now, where was Iโฆoh yes. You Pruetts always leave my family out of the discussion!โ
โWho are you?โ
โI am Tony Corleonesi, descendent of Thaddeus Maier, son of Donovan Pruett, son of Xavier Pruett, the founder of the Pruett legacy. That makes us cousins.โ Tony laughed maniacally.
Jonathan was extremely confused. โWho is Thaddeus Maier? We donโt have anyone in the family by that name!โ
โSee! This is what Iโm talking about! I know your family history better than you do! Donovan Pruett had two sons. Your grandfather, Aiden, andย my grandfather, Thaddeus. Donovan was in a relationship with my grandmother Mabel Maier whenย your trollop for a grandmother, Adalyn Darling, came and took him away. She ruined a perfectly good relationship, and Donovan married your trashy grandmother instead. Even when my grandmother tried to patch things up, he still threw us away.โ
โBut what does this have to do with anything? If this Thaddeus person was real, he would still be aย spare! We donโt owe you anything!โ
โAhhhh, but thatโs where youโre wrong, Mr. Legacy!ย You are living proof that spares can rise up and be in power! Wasnโt your grandfather once a spare?ย You would have been nobody too, but youโre not! Weโre going to rise up and take our rightful place in Pruett history! We will make this legacy greater than it has ever been! I even have a little heir on the way.โ
Jonathan felt like crying, but he couldnโt let Tony see that he had gotten to him. He failed. It was clear to him now. The Pruett legacy was definitely lost, and he let it slip right through his fingers like water flowing down the drain.
โDonโt you just love karma,โ Tony said.
โWhat happened to you, Tony? Did our friendship mean anything to you? Were you planning this the whole time?โ
โOf course not. Youโre a good guy, and we had fun. But, like I saidโฆIโm a family guy, and my family always comes first. You understand, right?โ
Jonathan couldnโt hear anymore. He couldnโt take it and gotย up and left.
โCome by the house anytime,โ Tony said. โIโd love to have a family reunion!โ His laughter was full of evil and malice.
Jonathan trudged out the door silently and took his shame, embarrassment, pain, and regret with him.














Oh, Tony, you sexy devilish gangster! What you did is awful, but I love you anyway…
Poor Jonathan. I feel for you, I really do. That backstabber Tony! You should steal the heirloom back.
I’m awful. I know it! lol
You are not! It’s just Tony, he’s himself…
I’m really torn now. I love both Tony and Jonathan and I loved their friendship soooo much!
Yeah! I was too. I was excited to do this from a writer’s perspective, but as a Simmer, I was sad to do it. I see Tony walking about the trailer, I’m like “that scumbag” LOL.
Oh. Snap. Again
srsly
Oh Tony… *sigh* Okay, now that that’s cleared up- what’s gonna happen next? Ugh I really want it to be finished but just so I know what happens! You have me really conflicted over here, girl!
he he, sorry? Three more chapters!
Dun, dun, DUNNNNNN!!!!! Tony! What a twist!!!!! I love it! ๐ I can’t wait to read more to see how this all ends!
Three more chapters!!
I love it!! ๐
Tony is a plumhead after all! Sigh. I felt like I was also blindsided by who he really was and his motivation for betraying Jonathan which was actually a pretty cool twist.
Thank you! I’ve been nervous about you guys’ reactions to this.
Nooooo….I was holding out for Tony, maybe it could’ve been a misunderstanding or something ๐ I loved the dynamic between them—but I knew after Jonathan signed over the Power of Attorney, something was going to go wrong ๐ Excited to see how he fixes it, but still bummed Tony turned out to be the villain after all.
Yeah…he has a bit of a reputation among some of us :-\
Mwayayayaya! That’s hilarious!
Hilarious?? HA! That’s great. So not the response I was expecting! I’m waiting for someone to hate me lol. I think I know who that someone will be, he he he.
I think it’s awesome! I seriously love it–stroke of genius! In a backwards way, it sort of reminds me of when Robinsons got Oakenstead–backwards because they deserved it, whereas Meatballs stole it! But still, when you’ve got a dynasty, there are going to be all sorts of stray cousins and siblings running around! It’s so historical! Plus, something feels so very, very right to me about Johnathan not having a lot and having to work his way back to having something. His heart was in the right place, and he really loves Skyla, but things came so very easy. I feel like this is just what he needs!
You’re so right! I LOVE Jonathan, but I like him and Skyla so much more now that they’re broke. You’ll see in a couple days. Now that it’s over, I’ve considered putting them back, but…it just doesn’t feel right! They’re still in the trailer although it’s slightly bigger and nicer now.
That’s so awesome! I feel like he’ll be able to really give his kids something now! If they were rich, what would he give his kids? Just stuff! Now he can give his kids what they need to really live! ๐
And not even stuff because they have everything! You’re going to love the last two chapters. ๐
Hahahaha. Now you can start again with Jonathan as gen 1!!!! ๐ (the legacy that never ends.)
No, lie, I have seriously considered starting another Pruett legacy LOL. Iโm not doing it though. I need to let them goโฆ
I am, however, considering doing some sort of continuation of this story generations later. Not exactly a comeback story, but kinda. Weโll see what happens.
Mind. Blown.
Yaaaas! ๐
Ahhhhhh!!! I’m freaking out over here!!
Arenโt you glad I didnโt spoil it for ya?
What a twist! I feel so mad at Meatball..and I’m disappointed in Johnathan for trusting him lol.
Yeah. Both sides are pretty crummy.
I guess the bromance was too good to be true *sigh* lol …. good twist….
Thank you ๐
Brilliant! I would have never guessed To y was related to the Pruetts. What an epic twist! Love it! *evil laugh*
lol, yay! All your suspicions weren’t wasted, eh? ๐